Hindu Christian relations – what are the foci of new ways of looking at these?
Joshva
Hinduism-
First we need to recognise the
fact that Hinduism is often claimed to be a culture than a religion. Hinduism
holds together a diverse traditional ways of life, teachings and beliefs that
are at time contrary to each other. This is certainly not part of Abrahamic
family of religions or people of the book.
It does not have a founder or a doctrine to hold it together as one
single religious group or under one leadership either. Many Hindus who follow Vedas, Gita, Upanisads and
other Sanskrit texts. Many Hindus follow Saiva Siddhantha texts in Tamil and
other languages. Other Hindus follow
Ramakrishna Mission which is reformed
version of Hinduism and there a wide range of such groups and activities. Some
of these followings have caste based reformed groups such as Sri Narayana Guru
movements and other counter movements from among Backward communities. Many
Dalits follow a different kind of religion altogether without any Sanskrit
version of Hindu religion. Some Dalits think that they are not Hindus at all. Buddhists
and Jains claim to be different religious groups though their origins are from
Hindu reformation. With the interaction of Christianity Hindu religious groups
have evolved such as Brahmo Samaj and other guru movements. Even Sikhism is
claimed to be an outcome of interaction between Islam and Hindu
traditions. Recently there are
evangelical movements among Hindus presenting very positive image of Hinduism
all over the world through Hare Ram Hare Krishna movements. Besides this a lot of modern popular gurus
have evolved to spread yoga as a spiritual tradition around the world. Some
revival and charismatic Gurus have also evolved claiming to reform political,
cultural and religious traditions in India such as Sri Sri Ravi Shankar. In
short Hinduism is understood to be a variety of traditions that come together
in India and now spread all over the world through migration and other forms.
Secondly recently Hindus have undergone a lot of changes
both in thinking and approaching other religions. Usually Hinduism is an
accommodative religion in many places in India. But due to worldwide
interactions through diaspora, marginalisation of Hindu minorities and
political aspirations, Hindus have become aware of the need to unite themselves
and to find something in common among those who claim to be Hindus. In many
contexts such identity crisis since 1930 particularly among Diaspora and
minority Hindus had resulted in developing a new ideology known as Hindutva. Some political groups overseas starting from
Trinidad to India have used such political aspirations and ideologies for their
own vote bank politics. But one has to recognise the fact that among diaspora
there is also struggle to preserve their identities as Hindus though
traditionally, culturally and linguistically they were diverse.
In 1920s Trinidad Groups such as Arya Samaj brought Hindu reformist agenda
and thus created awareness about Hindu Orthodoxy (Sanatan Dharm). They tried to
evolve a Hindu ideology that will make them distinct from other cultural
groups. There were attempts to unify all the groups among the diaspora Hindus.
Many of them contributed towards caste, sectarian and linguistic needs rather
than a homogenous group was formed among Hindus. In 1950s Mahasaba (Hindus
Association) began to run Satung, Pujas, yagnas similar to Catholic practices
in Trinidad. They began to define God and creed which were something new to
Hinduism but became a reality among diaspora Hindus. A systematic termination
of unofficial Hinduism by the popular Brahmanic Hinduism was effective even
among diaspora communities. The castes both in the form of vegetarianism and
relating to ritual activities enabled communities to maintain the division and
social strata among Hindus. Among the Hindu diaspora the Christian
denominations have made huge impact on structuring their faith, practices and
cultural groups but on the basis of hindu dharm (Hindu rules). So the new emerging Hindutva in the form of
neo-Hinduism was a binding force and provided a strategy for upward mobility
both politically and economically. [resources: Marion
O'Callaghan Hinduism in the Indian
Diaspora in Trinidad 1998, Journal of Hindu-Christian Studies]In Britain, National Council of Hindu Temples and Viraat Hindu Sammelan tried to unify all the Hindus under their one Hindu ideological formation with Vaishnavaite Bhakti movements. This also attempted to give raise to ethnic Hindu communalism.
Third Hindu Nationalism also has contributed toward the
formation of Hindutva movements. Their first argument was against colonial
government which they linked with colonial religion – Christianity. But for
Hindus Islam was also an outside religion and was brought into India through
occupation and power struggles. Hindutva groups are so doctrinized using the
examples from Goa (South West Indian state) where temples were destroyed and
the churches were built. Considerable number of people was converted by
Portuguese into a Catholic Christianity [1510-1610]. Also a similar case is
made against Islam as well in terms of forcible conversions. Thus all the
colonial governments are blamed for the spread of Christianity in India. Particularly
Hindutva movements are worried about the popularity of Western cultural values
and practices in India such as Valentines day and other days. They argued that
the fall of Indian conservative culture is due to the popularity of Western
culture which is because of the Christian minorities who were blamed often as
agents of such Western cultures.
Hindu nationalists demand that Indian Christians today take
up the Indian culture and thus become Indians first then Christians. Such
arguments are also supported by a few Syrian Orthodox priests who also support
the Hindutva movements politically in Kerala and also nationally at times. Such popularity of Hindutva movements and
Hindu nationalists political parties were possibly mainly due to the funding of
the diaspora groups and influenced by strong groups such as Vishwa Hindu
Parisad overseas committees. After liberalisation of economy in India, overseas
Indian began to invest in India and also began to support the Hindu nationalist
movements and also financed Hindutva groups.
Hinduism as many traditions and cultural groups kept
changing like other religious traditions and groups according to the need of
different contexts and different historical settings.
Today the relationship between Christians and Hindus are one
of complex in nature. Many Hindus in India appreciate Christian contribution
towards education, health and other social developmental institutions. There
are various ways Hindus have responded towards Christian faith, Christian
institutions and Christians. In some places resistance, rejection, oppression,
confrontation and persecution and marginalisation are the ways of responding to
Christians. In many places cooperation, partnership, jointly working together,
friendship and in various positive relations are often the ways to relate to
Christians. In some places conversion, assimilation and accommodation are the ways
to engage with Christians.
But in terms of Hindu Christian relations, Fr Michael
Amaldoss and also Michael Fitzgerald have already distinguished four different
levels of dialogue: the dialogue of life; the dialogue of intellectual
exchange; the dialogue of spiritual experience and the dialogue of common
action[1].
I also realise similar distinctions are made by Mr Peter Kemp in his article on
Towards a Dialogue of Learning and
Criticism, in which he expands Fr Amaldoss’ into detailed distinctions[2].
My distinctions are based on the three major Margas of Srimad Bagavad Gita and my own
addition of Jeeva Marga after reading Fr Amaldoss’ dialogue for life. These
margas will be used when we analyse the dialogue and modern means of
communication. In the Dominus Iesus
(Declaration on the Unicity and Salvific Universality of Jesus Christ and the
Church, August 6, 2000)
inter-religious dialogue is seen as part of the churches’ evangelizing mission[3].
Equality in dialogue refers to the equal personal dignity of the parties in
dialogue, not to doctrinal content. In this way inter-religious dialogue can be
seen as an important responsibility of the church in doing mission and
ministry.
Four Margas
First Inter-religious
communication involves a process of establishing contact, discussion,
interaction and relationship between different religious communities. This
effort is basically to establish some common ground on which people from
different religions can live, communicate, act and interact together. It aims
at knowing the basics of the other and trying to understand the other. This
might remove ignorance that one may have about the other. This communication
should lead to a coexistence of different religious communities. Discussions
can be based on addressing issues related to a life together. This can also be
possible both at leadership and grassroots level. I classify such dialogic
attempt as Jeeva Marga (the Path of
Life)[4]. In this path three stages of communication
are essential to follow that are contact (thodarbu
– in Tamil – Rev Thomas Thangaraj uses this term), relationship (uravu), understanding (arivu). Through
this dialogue we need to establish these three stages of communication. It is
also reflected in the present Pope’s statement to the Indian Bishops on 26th June 2003[5],
Inter-religious dialogue will not only increase mutual understanding and
respect for one another but will also help to develop society in harmony with
the rights and dignity for all. This clearly shows that at leadership level the
churches wanted to encourage the people to engage in dialogue and thus coexist
with other religious communities in harmony and peace with justice and human
dignity. The best example is Duyog Ramadan [Fitzgerald 2004:2] in Southern Philippines. This programme helps Christians
accompany (Duyog) Muslims during the month of Ramadan. Through Radio, sermons
and talks the Christians are made aware of how Muslims observe Ramadan.
Secondly Interfaith Action involves
a process of acting together in the social processes such as eliminating the
poverty, exploitation and corruption in our society. This effort is to work
together towards the betterment of human beings and human society in general.
It can be identified as Karma Marga (the
Path of Action)[6]. In Bangalore
we have dialogue groups that exist with different purposes. One of them is in
Whitefield Asrham of Guru Prabhakar where he introduces the concept of action
together – which he calls Annaprasadha (sharing
of food). This programme is held once in two weeks in villages where people
come together before a religious shrine, bring different food items and cook
the food together and share it with all. Regardless of religions people are
expected to come and join in this meal sharing. This is not a charity
(Annadhana) though all share this food. Even in my campaign against conversion
bill introduced by Tamil Nadu Government many Muslims and Hindus joined us in
the public procession. Inter-religious dialogue should lead us towards
communicative action. The dialogic communication should lead us towards
community building, human dignity and support of local cultures. World
Conference on Religion and Peace (WCRP) focus mainly on dialogue for action.
WCRP has contributed towards the setting up of an inter-religious council in Sarajevo and also a similar one Sierra Leone which is engaged in
the rehabilitation of child soldiers [Fitzgerald 2004:3].
Thirdly Inter-religious
Experience involves engaging in each other’s search for meanings of life and of
God and thus making a search for ultimate reality and take all together towards
God. It also involves in participating in each other’s religious activities to
test and find whether some of them are meaningful, relevant, nourishing and
useful to all. This effort is basically to learn more about each other’s
spirituality and faith. It can be identified as Bhakti Marga (the Path of Devotion)[7].
Here the spirituality forms the basis of dialogue between people.
Particularly those elements that are used for spiritual experience can also be
shared among different communities[8].
When I tune or compose Bhajans in Sanskrit, in Telugu and in Tamil somewhat the
UTC students and others like them and so sing them often. Interestingly we
found some of these Bhajans transcend the religious barriers, in particular the
music. Some of the Bhajans or tunes are immediately borrowed by other religious
communities [Ariarajah[9]
1999]. Symbol, signs, rituals, lyrics, music or acoustic instruments enable
people to transcend their religious barriers. People recognise the similarities
in spiritual experiences in different religions. Kabir is a poet who brought different
traditions together in his Urudu poems. G U Pope a great Western missionary and
Tamil Scholar who read thiruvasagam and commented if you are not shedding your
tears while reading Tiruvasagam (A Tamil Saiva siddhanda religious poetical
text) you will not shed your tears for any other book. The spirituality has
brought people together. The dialogue can focus on sharing people’s different
spiritual experiences and their bhakti traditions.
Fourthly Interfaith Search refers
to a participation in the search for the ultimate reality through intellectual
discussions and exercises. There should be a space for dialogue that leads to
an intellectual exchange between different religious communities. Such an
exchange would continue to nourish each other’s faith and enable them to listen
together with people of science, people without any faith and people with different
ideologies. This can be identified as Jnana
and Dhyana Marga (the Path of Knowledge and Meditation)[10].
I added Dhyana intentionally because no search begin from outside in Indian
thinking and so begin discovering self. Only when we begin to discover our self
we begin to learn little bit about the Self and thus our relationship with the
other ‘self’s. In all the above stated margas neither change of religion nor
any mission from one religion to other can happen but people learn together,
listen to each other and thus grow in their respective faith. This is a process
of sharing, learning and listening together. I was engaged in a number of
dialogue programmes. One of them was a controversial dialogue between Christian
leaders and Rashtriya Sweyam Sevaksangh (RSS) in Bangalore 2002. The leader Mr
Sudhersan was leading the RSS and a few Bishops were leading Christians. During
the first half the dialogue was a failure because both blaming each other and
defending their own positions. The dialogue was successful to some extent that
both critically engaged with the other and slowly was trying to understand the
other. It led them to a conclusion that we need to engage in a continuous
dialogue with each other.
It is also a search together the relevant
meanings of religion, of community and of life. It is a search for the ultimate
reality or truth. In this dialogue one can engage in the other’s search for
meanings and thereby learn together. This dialogue often remains at
intellectual and representatives level. In the guidelines to Nostra Aetate No 4, the Vatican
Commission demanded the dialogue members to go beyond friendly talks and
identify those competent people to meet and to study together the many problems
deriving from the fundamental convictions of Judaism and Christianity[11].
I agree with Dr Samartha (1991: 59) that Dialogue is between
people and so it much a matter of relationships, discussions and communication.
There can be no dialogue between ‘faiths’ or ‘religions’ or ‘ideologies’[12].
Dialogue is communication between the two persons or communities. From an
Islamic perspective Dialogue is a dimension of human consciousness (not
sceptical), a category of the ethical sense (not cynical). It is the altruistic
arm of Islam and Christianity, their reach beyond themselves. Dialogue in short
is the only kind of inter-human relationship worthy of human beings[13].
Different types and means of communication can enhance the inter-religious
dialogue. This is already recognised by S J Samartha in his writings. He argues
that not only the symbols of religious life and practice, particularly music,
art, devotion, meditation and the controlled use of silence but also the verbal
communication are essential part of the dialogue. (Samartha, 1981:7)[14].
R Panikkar pointed out new ways of engaging with Hindus by
saying, “I do not accept the
all-too-frequent understanding of dialogue, that is, discussion for the sake of
finding points of agreement under the assumption that it is the points of
agreement that tell us what the various religions are really about. Such an
assumption makes a mockery of religious discourse and is not necessary for
dialogue to take place. Indeed, in dialogue there should be the possibility for
a fair bit of disagreement as well as agreement. The issue in dialogue is not
agreement or disagreement, but an attitude of openness and seeing the other as
significant in the exchange of ideas and the argumentation that is aimed at
understanding and allows for the possibility of both education and change.” (p.
42) [Hindu Christian Dialogue
Hindu-Christian Dialogue: Perspectives and Encounters (Faith Meets Faith)
Paperback by Harold Coward (Author)
1990, Orbis].
Dialogue for Life (coexistence of and friendly relations
between Hindus and Christians)
Dialogue of spiritual Experience (sharing spiritual
experiences through Bhakti)
Dialogue for Action (Working together towards liberation,
social development and changing attitude)
Dialogue for Intellectual search (asking common questions
about God and other concepts)
These are the ways Hindu Christians relations cherished in
India and elsewhere. But now the context has changed. On the one hand Hindutva
movements and ideologies promote hatred towards Christians and other minorities
through myths, stories and ignorance. Also the Hindu popular guru movements are
promoting self-centred realizations, yoga for good health and positive attitude
type of doctrines that becomes not only popular but also makes money for such
gurus. Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Rastrya SwayamSevak Sangh and other Hindutva
groups have promoted not only hindu unifying ideologies but also a hatred
attitude towards minorities in general.
In 1997 four questions were raised in an interaction between
Hindu Christians intellectual friends that are:
-What is
our responsibility as Hindus and/or Christians, when proselytisation and
religious extremism destroy the fibre of the "one world family?"
- What is
our responsibility as Hindus and/or Christians to ensure that our religious
traditions do not condone discrimination based on caste?
- What is
our responsibility as Hindus and/or Christians to really understand the
self-definition of the other, respecting the language and meaning used for it?
- What is
our responsibility as Hindus and/or Christians to take further steps in
Hindu-Christian relations on the local, regional, national and international
level?
In this context, among Diaspora communities, the best ways
to engage in dialogue and establish better relations are:
1.
Listening to Hindus - It is time to listen to Hindus
Listening to the critique of Hindus towards Christian
colonial mistakes
Listening to the critique of Hindus towards Christians’ ways
of doing conversion
Listening to the critique of Hindus towards the issues of
increasing marginalization of Hindus outside India
Listening to diverse voices within and among Hindu
traditions towards coexistence and cherishing cooperation in charity and
development work
Listening to diverse voices within Hindu traditions and
cultures about castes and diverse views and ways of addressing discrimination
in general
Proselytization and religious extremism certainly destroy
the fabric of the society though at times majority Hindus are not against
conversion into another religion except through improper means (inducement, force, threat, violence,
persuasion through indirect or direct means).
2.
Sharing the success stories of cooperation and
coordination among Hindus and Christians in terms of relationship, actions,
experiences and growth
How, where and why the working
together is successful?
Can we read the scriptures
together?
Can we find a ways of working
together in social and community development?
Can we find common word between
Hindus and Christians?
Can Christians and Hindus work
towards life-affirming and life-sustaining social, ecological, cultural and
economic climate?
Can we raise together issues of
human rights?
3.
Educating Christians about Hinduism and Hindus
about Christianity – religious education with a focus on mutual understanding,
mutual respect and mutual appreciation along with mutual critical appraisal and
mutual growth
Can we address together Christian
fundamentalism (both local and overseas) and also Hindu fundamentalism
4.
Trialogue – taking dialogic relations to a new
level, understanding and education – building a relationship between Muslims
and Hindus through the engagement of Christians – Anglicans
5.
Talking about Minorities – Christian and Muslim
Minorities and also about Hindu minorities in Muslim countries
6.
Addressing Conflicts, confrontations and
discrimination together as friends
A panel of Hindus to listen to (to be challenged by them)
A panel to people who are already engaged in successful
experiences of working together as Hindus and Christians
A panel to discuss about addressing caste, differently able
people and women discrimination and a comparative study
A panel to raise issues and identify future possibilities
between Hindus and Christians and highlight the area of education for both
sides
[1]
Michael Amaldoss, "Freedom in the Spirit and Interreligious
Dialogue", Studies in Interreligious Dialogue 8 (1998) 5-18.
Michael Fitzgerald, Developing Dialogue,
2004. (Dialogue of Life; Dialogue of Action; Dialogue of theological exchange;
Dialogue of religious experience). Mr Sean Dwan suggests Discursive dialogue
(debate), human dialogue (Buber-meeting as human beings), Secular dialogue
(joint action), spiritual dialogue – from the Inter-religious dialogue, www.Dwaninterreligiousdialogue.org
[2]
Peter Kemp, Towards A Dialogue of Learning and Criticism,
A Paper presented at the International Conference on the Dialogue of
Civilizations, United Nations University, 3rd August 2001, Kyoto. His distinctions are: 1. The Dialogue
in ordinary life and practice 2. The dialogue in intellectual exchange of
interpretations of life and practice 3.The dialogue in mutual effort for
discovering common experiences and complementary despite differences 4.The
dialogue between human beings sharing the same historical experiences of values
and beliefs.
[3]
Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith – Dominus Iesus: Declaration on the Unicity and Salvific Universality of
Jesus Christ and the Church, August
6, 2000. www.bc.ed/research/cjl/meta-elements/texts/documents/catholic/cdf-dominusiesus
[4]
Advesta sarvabhutanam maitrah karuna eva ca friendly
and compassionate to all
nirmamo nirahamkarah sama
dhukha sukha ksami and without any
touch of hatred devoid of
possessiveness and arrogance
santustah satatam yogi
yatatma dradha niscayah ever
content and contemplative alike happiness and
misery, self controlled and firm in
conviction
mayy arpita mano buddhir yo
mad bhaktah sa me priyah dedicated to
me with all his heart and all his soul
is the real devotee to me and is
dear to me.
(Sri Gita 12:12)
[5]
Extra ecclesium nulla salus, ‘Inter-religious Dialogue is Part of Evangelising
mission, Pope says.. It Implies Profound Respect for Culture He tells Indian
Bishops’, Vatican City,
June 26, 2003, http://www.tcrnews2.com/genjp2000.html
[6]
Sri Gita 5: 7 – one who is
established in selfless and detached action, who is pure, whose mind and senses
are under control and whose self is identified with the self of all – he is
never bound though he be engaged in work. 5:12 By abandoning the fruits of action (service to
others) a man of restrained mind attains to abiding peace.
[7]
Sarva Bhuta stham atmanam
sarva bhutani cathmani – The person of spiritual insight, established in
same sightedness sees the Self as
residing in all beings
iksathe
yoga yuktatama sarvatra samadaranah – and all beings as resting in the
Self. Sri Gita 6:29
[8]
Giuseppe Scattolin, Spirituality in
inter-religious Dialogue:Challenge and Promise. In Encounter, 274, April 2001.
[9]
S Wesley Ariarajah, ‘Dialogue and Spirituality: Can We Pray together?’ Chapter
3 of Not Without My Neighbor: Issues in
Interfaith Relations. Geneva:World
Council of Churches, 1999, pp.26-58.
[10]
Sri Gita 7:23-26 Those who
worship the Devas go to Devas, but my devotees attain to me. People with little
knowledge look upon me as a mere human individual, having come manifestation
from an unmanifested state. I know all beings – past present and future. But
none knows me.
[11]
Guidelines on Nostra Aetate 1974…
[12]
S J Samartha, “Inter-religious Relationships in the Secular
State’ in Interfaith Dialogue and World Community edited by Mr Ch Sreenivasa
Rao, 1991, Madras:CLS.
[13] Isma’il Ragi A. Al Faruqi, ‘Islam and
Christianity:Diatribe or Dialogue’, in Muslims
in Dialogue: The Evolution of a Dialogue. L Swidler, ed The Edwn Mellen
Press, Lewiston, NY, pp.1-22, 1992.
[14]
S J Samartha, Courage for
Dialogue:Ecumenical Issues in Inter-religious Relationships. Geneva:WCC, 1981.